Arrivano gli Atenei virtuosi! ll cosiddetto pacchetto universita' presentato da Mariastella Gelmini e approvato dal Consiglio dei ministri establish a ranked list of universities that will share a virtuoso performance reserve fund of about EUR 525 million.
I could be wrong, but I fear that this "assessment" had a strong economic weight indexes. At first glance it seems to me to be rewarded in particular small and medium sized universities with fewer people, who for spending on salaries were kept below 90% of the fund so ordinary (FFO). In this way you get the absurd to penalize faculties or departments of value, only because they belong to universities on average more profligate than others.
Regarding teaching, I have some doubts here. A criterion used consideration was the number of students enrolled in the second year who have passed at least two-thirds of the examinations. In this way, however, are promoted university-esamifici where it is easier to pass exams, while the more selective poor educational outcomes. It was also decided to reward the universities whose students have found jobs within three years after graduation. The assumption, compete wrong, is that finding work in Italy is the exclusive function of the value of a degree is completely independent of the socio-economic conditions of a given region or other "variables" more homemade.
's still unclear what were the criteria valutazione della ricerca e delle pubblicazioni scientifiche, anche se si legge che sono stati presi in considerazioni i giudizi del Civr.
Insomma, mi sbaglierò, ma al momento queste classifiche sembrano frutto di un lavoro estemporaneo, approssimativo e poco meditato che ha prodotto stime inesatte. A mio parere, piuttosto che interi Atenei, spesso molto eterogenei al loro interno, sarebbe più corretto valutare le singole Facoltà o i singoli Dipartimenti.
0 comments:
Post a Comment